Looking for something besides cake or cupcakes? We offer a variety of other treats at Magpies. Our selection in store rotates daily, so it is best to preorder if you are looking for something specific.

Minimum order of 1 dozen per flavor.
Plain Jane Brownies $2.50 each
Iced Brownies and Bars $4 each

Twix Brownies
Cookies n Cream Brownies
Oreo Birthday Brownies
Reese’s Brownies
Candy Bar Brownies
Cookie Dough Brownies
S’mores Brownies
Turtle Brownies
Sugar Cookie Bars
Cinnamon Roll Blondies
Lemon Blueberry Bars

5” (2-4 servings) $18
9” (10-14 servings) $48

*available year round*
New York
Peanut Butter

*available January-March*
Chocolate Raspberry
Oreo

*available April-August*
Oreo
Cookie Monster
Strawberry

*available September-November*
Caramel Toffee
Pumpkin

*available in December*
Chocolate Raspberry
Peppermint Bark

*available to order with one week notice*
9” (7-10 servings)

Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Pecan
Buttermilk Chess
Key Lime
Cherry*
* depending on availability

Seasonal Pies
Grasshopper
Strawberry Cream
Strawberry Rhubarb
Blueberry
Peach
Pumpkin
Winterberry
Almond Joyous

Priced each / dozen

Lemon Thumbprint $2/$18
Chocolate Cherry $2/$18
Chocolate Chip $2/$18
Sugar $2/$18
Peanut Butter $2/$18
M&M $2/$18

Chocolate Chip Sammies $5/$54
Lil Peggy’s Oatmeal Cream Pies $5/$54
Sugar Sammies $5/$54